Agencies often look the same on paper. The best redesign partner thinks about your team, your users, your long-term needs and your best interests, and will be candid with you even if it costs them work.
Let’s frame the situation.
You’re looking at a redesign. Maybe it’s based on a new CMS, or maybe it’s driven by a need to modernize. You’ve shortlisted three or four agencies, and each one brings a great portfolio of past work and the technical chops to handle the work. Prices are all pretty close — some higher, some lower.
On paper, you’re still trying to decide which one to pick, so the design starts to slide toward price, or a gut feeling about the people in the room. It starts sliding to experience in your field, or a shorter timeline. Regardless, you know all of these firms can handle the project.
The truth of the agency space right now is that there are a lot of very talented shops that provide great design and great development — enough that it’s starting to get hard to tell them apart, which means something else is going to drive the decision.
Usually, that something else is price. Price wins by default if every agency looks the same. But remember that you are only comparing agencies based on what they’re willing to show you. A portfolio is a snapshot, and vendor certifications only last a short amount of time. What you’re really buying is a relationship — two years, three years, maybe a decade. And it’s rare to get a feel for that over a design portfolio and development certifications.
So, how do you judge a relationship before you’ve had a chance to work with them? More importantly, will any of these agencies think about you when you’re not in the room?
It’s all about thinking beyond the portfolio.
Every agency is going to tell you that you’re the most important client, especially during the pitch. But how can you actually tell? Here are a few things that we try to bring out during our pitches in order to show that the relationship is a two-sided partnership.
Thinking about your team.
Often lost in all of the back and forth between features and design methods and tools and CMS selection is that actual human people will be using this new site. You can tell an agency that’s ready to be a partner by whether or not they ask questions about those people. Who are they? What is their process? What pain points are they trying to solve?
This is what we might call governance, and it should be folded into any discussion around choosing a tool, like a CMS. The right CMS is one that your team can operate without calling the agency whenever there’s a hiccup, and the right CMS needs to be able to manage content within the mental model that your team thinks about content.
How to be sure: Ask your potential partners about the content model. How do they determine fields, connections, and interactions? Then, ask them to describe the editor experience (in addition to the visitor experience). Also, keep an ear out — if they want to meet with your editorial team in addition to stakeholders, they’re already thinking about the human side of the site.
Thinking about your users.
Every agency is going to tell you that they’re thinking about the end user, but this is a point to make sure they’re thinking about every user, including those who might not use the website every day, or those who have disabilities that prevent them from easily navigating the web.
An agency that’s thinking of everyone is an agency that puts accessibility front and center. They think past their own design team to people they’ll rarely, if ever, meet. They design with contrast in mind, and develop with screen readers in mind. They understand every person comes to the site with a different perspective — and, literally, a different screen width.
How to be sure: Ask your potential partners when accessibility is addressed — is it throughout, or just a check at the end? Ask if they know the WCAG level required within your industry. Don’t just let them talk about best practices — have them show you the best practices, and confirm they understand the “why” behind the “how.”
Thinking about your future.
When is a website considered “finished?” For a good design partner, the answer is probably closer to “never.” We know that websites are living documents, always changing and evolving, which means we need to make sure we’ve got the right team to help keep things moving.
There are really two sides of this, and choosing the right agency means understanding what your team needs in the first place.
- If you hope to rely on an agency partner, listen to how they talk about ongoing support. What attention and priority will you have. Are they deep integration partner, or are they expecting to manage everything down to content changes? Are they building something they stand behind enough that they can continue to maintain it?
- If you hope to maintain the site on your own, listen to how they hand things off. Could you own this site if you wanted to, and will they help train your development team on how to maintain the CMS itself? Will you depend on the agency to help you take off on your own, or are they manufacturing some kind of reliance on their team?
How to be sure: Ask what handoff looks like. Do they have a plan for the future, regardless of what you are looking for? And if they say no about something, is it a technical fact or is part of how they lock in the relationship?
Thinking about your best interests.
This fourth one is set out on its own, because it underlines everything we've said already. Candidness is not a deliverable, and guidance is not something you can put a dollar amount on. An agency that will do everything you ask is not protecting the relationship as much as it’s protecting the invoice.
If a potential partner is steering you toward a specific tool, ask for proof. The best partners have deep relationships with specific vendors, but will also tell you when a vendor is the wrong choice. They’ll gladly identify if your CMS selection is overkill — too much cost and technology for your site’s needs — and vice versa; they will urge you to go bigger when they know something like Wordpress isn’t going to cut it.
More than anything, they’ll be candid. A partnership thrives on candidness. They know the tools well enough to know when they fail.
How to be sure: Ask a partner to name a specific time they talked a client out of a vendor or tool choice, or when they recommended “less.”
It’s all about details.
So let’s head back to the top. You’re looking at a redesign, and you’ve got a short list of agencies that can definitely help you out.
Which means the differentiation shifts from capability to relationship. What do the two years after launch look like? Do they ask about your team, or only your stakeholders? Is accessibility a standard at every stage? How much leverage do you have when it comes to support — and does it match what you need?
None of these things are going to show up in a portfolio; instead, you’ll have to ask the questions. Build them into your RFP, if you’d like, but also know that the most truthful answers will come during the presentation, when they’re going through their prepared slides. Ask the important questions, and you’ll immediately start to see which agencies are thinking about you when you’re not in the room.
